A couple of weeks ago, I got a call from a friend who was asking about breastfeeding during pregnancy. It wasn't the first such call I've received; this happens surprisingly often. As the conversation continued, my newly pregnant friend asked me about circumcision. Her first child was a girl, so she had never given thought to it, but with the possibility that this new baby could be a boy, it was now on her radar.
I started, "We probably won't...." then I stopped and changed gears, "We will not circumcise Isaac."
Later I thought about my nervousness in being bold about this issue. You all know my penchant for avoiding hot topics on my blog! I've considered blogging about circumcision before, but because Margaret was a girl, I didn't feel like I could do it. But now I have a boy. A beautiful intact, whole little boy.
Before I was pregnant with Margaret, I knew nothing about circumcision. Circumcision was something everyone did; I didn't know any intact men or boys. I did know that early Christians were told not to circumcise because Christ's atonement fulfilled the law, but because I didn't know any intact men or boys, I assumed that either 1) it was counsel specific to that time, like how women were supposed to wear head coverings or 2) there must be significant evidence to show a benefit to circumcision. I mean, a doctor wouldn't recommend something that was harmful, right?
Then I got pregnant and I started questioning that line of thinking. I also started trying to find people who wouldn't keel over when I mentioned "unassisted" and "childbirth" in the same sentence. And guess what? I found those people. And those people had intact sons. And they were passionate about keeping their boys intact. They were intactivists.
I went to playgroups with those intactivists. Alisa was one of the biggest intactivists and through her rants and her blog, I was led to look further into the research. Point number 2 was debunked. I couldn't find any evidence that circumcision would be beneficial. In my quest to do "only that which I knew was good for my baby," I couldn't say circumcision would be good. In fact, one friend pointed out that while the chance of a baby dying from loss of blood in a circumcision is very small, it's still higher than the chance of a baby dying from staying intact.
There was a sexual aspect, too. The closest analogous structure to the foreskin for me is the clitoral hood. That's an important sexual part of my body. I couldn't take that away from my sons. That's just cruel.
There was also the practical aspect: I was planning a peaceful, intervention-free birth at home. One of the reasons I wanted such a birth was so that I could ease into motherhood and bond with my baby with as little interruption as possible. So it didn't make sense to pick everybody up and head to a doctor to remove a son's foreskin. That whole scenario Did Not Compute.
But what about point number 1? The woman who led the UCAN meetings I attended made up a pamphlet about circumcision and Latter-day Saint teachings (first one under "circumcision pamphlets" on the left sidebar. It quoted modern LDS scripture about circumcision. The part that struck me most was, "that the tradition might be done away." Reading that, it sounded clear to me that God doesn't want us to circumcise our babies. He wants the whole ordeal to be "done away" with or in simpler terms, "Hey everybody! Stop circumcising your boys! I don't want you to do that!" For me, that was the clincher. If I were to circumcise my sons, I would be directly going against God's counsel and I couldn't do that.
Isaac is one month old today and I am already glad we've made the decision to keep him intact. With the thrush came an awful thrush diaper rash. I can't imagine fighting thrush in his diaper along with trying to heal an open wound. I'm sure that would have made his already miserable diaper changes worse. I've been in tears over how I inadvertently caused his thrush and making his early life full of pain; I can't imagine the blubbery mess I'd be if I were to willfully cause pain with a circumcision. That just goes against my mama sense.
Along with the links above, check these out:
Doctors Opposing Circumcision
Intact America
The Case Against Circumcision
This post was about how I decided to keep my sons intact; I'll also be doing a post about a few more social and cultural aspects of circumcision.